Surge in Prediction Market ETF Filings as SEC Delays Approvals

Surge in Prediction Market ETF Filings as SEC Delays Approvals

Growing Number of Prediction Market ETF Proposals

A wave of filings for exchange-traded funds (ETFs) linked to prediction markets is intensifying pressure on regulators, particularly the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), to establish clear rules for these products. So far, however, the SEC has not approved any prediction-market ETFs, leaving issuers and investors in limbo.

The trend became more visible earlier this year when Roundhill Investments submitted plans for a series of funds designed to hold baskets of political derivatives traded on yes/no exchanges. Bitwise and GraniteShares soon followed suit, but the SEC quickly paused the approval process for these electoral-event contract ETFs, stating it needed additional time to evaluate what it called “novel” fund structures.

According to analysts at Cornerstone Research, an economic and financial consulting firm, these latest filings broaden the scope beyond politics. They now include economic outcomes tied to technology-sector layoffs, recession risk, and prices in cryptocurrency and oil markets. Another issuer has proposed a range of ETFs that, if approved, would hold baskets of event contracts related to climate, economic, and policy decisions. To date, the SEC has not approved any of these products.

More recently, at least three issuers filed plans for a staggering 128 ETFs—including 32 leveraged funds—that would effectively allow investors to bet on NHL team performance.

Regulatory Delays and the SEC’s Response

The SEC’s public comment period on these novel ETFs is set to close at the end of this month. However, Cornerstone’s experts caution that this deadline does not necessarily signal that further regulatory action is imminent. They note that the request for comment is not tied to a proposed rule, and the SEC has not indicated whether it will act on pending filings before or after any resulting proposal.

The analysts also point to two other key factors that could determine which event contracts remain available as reference assets: the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)’s June 2026 rulemaking on prediction markets, and ongoing litigation over state-law preemption.

Key Risks and Uncertainties for Prediction Market ETFs

Cornerstone’s report flags several major risks facing prediction market ETFs. Beyond concerns over liquidity and concentration, these products raise questions about the potential for insider trading. Additionally, they remain caught in uncertainty over how the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) will treat them for tax purposes.

In a related development, an attorney criticized the CFTC after the agency allowed Kalshi to disregard orders from a New York court and continue offering its products in the state.