State Pressure Forces Prediction Market Pullbacks in Connecticut, Missouri

State Pressure Forces Prediction Market Pullbacks in Connecticut, Missouri

Overview of Prediction Market Retreats

Recent enforcement actions by state authorities have led to significant pullbacks in prediction market operations across the United States. In Connecticut and Missouri, regulators have issued cease-and-desist orders to several operators, forcing them to either withdraw or suspend specific services. This crackdown reflects growing concerns over the legality and ethics of prediction markets, particularly their impact on vulnerable consumers.

Meanwhile, broader legal battles and regulatory inquiries are shaping the future of gambling and prediction markets nationwide. From Tribal gaming disputes to lawmakers demanding transparency from major operators, the industry is facing unprecedented scrutiny.


Connecticut’s Regulatory Crackdown

Cease-and-Desist Orders Issued

Connecticut’s Department of Consumer Protection (DCP) has taken a firm stance against prediction markets, issuing cease-and-desist orders to nine operators last month. Three of these operators—ProphetX, Gemini, and Webull—have since withdrawn from the state. The DCP remains in communication with other companies, including Polymarket, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Robinhood, Novig, and Underdog.

DCP Commissioner Bryan Cafferelli emphasized the state’s commitment to protecting consumers: “Our actions sent a clear message. We will not tolerate illegal prediction market activity that preys upon the most vulnerable consumers.”

Dispute Over Withdrawal Claims

Despite the DCP’s statements, there is some uncertainty regarding ProphetX’s status. Prediction-market analyst Mick Bransfield disputed the agency’s announcement, claiming that ProphetX has not pulled out of Connecticut. This discrepancy highlights the complexities of enforcing state-level regulations in a rapidly evolving industry.


PrizePicks Suspends Team Picks in Missouri

In Missouri, PrizePicks has announced the suspension of its Team Picks product, a sports event-contract offering, citing “updated legal requirements for prediction markets.” The company clarified that existing Team Picks remain active, and its traditional fantasy sports product is unaffected. Customers can withdraw funds at any time, but no new entries will be accepted in the state.

Background of Enforcement

This move follows cease-and-desist notices issued by Missouri Attorney General Catherine Hanaway to several prediction market operators, including Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Underdog, Novig, and Crypto.com. Notably, PrizePicks was not among the companies that received a notice, suggesting proactive compliance on their part.


Tribal Gaming Dispute Reaches Supreme Court

The Cabazon Band of Cahuilla Indians has urged the Supreme Court to review a Third Circuit ruling favoring Kalshi, a prediction market operator. The Tribe argues that allowing Kalshi to operate without state or Tribal regulation undermines the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, which grants Tribes exclusive rights to regulate gaming activities on their lands.

Cabazon’s brief highlights broader implications for Tribal gaming nationwide, noting that the industry generated $46.2 billion in revenue in 2025. The Tribe’s argument draws support from recent Ninth Circuit rulings rejecting Kalshi’s preemption claims.


Lawmakers Investigate FanDuel’s VIP Program

Personalized Celebrity Videos Under Scrutiny

Sen. Richard Blumenthal and Reps. Paul Tonko and Valerie Foushee have escalated their inquiry into FanDuel’s VIP program, demanding detailed information about personalized celebrity videos sent to high-value customers. These videos, which include messages from athletes and entertainers, were reportedly sent as “tokens of appreciation” for customer loyalty.

Ethical Concerns

Lawmakers argue that these videos could encourage continued gambling, particularly for customers who have suffered significant losses. A notable example is a Bryce Harper video sent to a bettor who lost $1.5 million on the platform. FanDuel has until October 20 to provide all requested materials, including recipient wagering histories and selection criteria.


Casino Gambling Debate in South Carolina

Divergent Views in Gubernatorial Race

South Carolina’s gubernatorial candidates, Alan Wilson and Jermaine Johnson, reiterated their opposing positions on casino gambling during a recent debate. While Johnson supports allowing casinos if approved by a statewide referendum, Wilson remains opposed, pledging to veto casino legislation.

Legislative Hurdles

South Carolina does not permit voter-initiated referendums, meaning any casino gambling proposal must first pass through the Legislature. Earlier attempts to legalize casinos and online sports betting have failed to gain traction, with Governor Henry McMaster maintaining a staunch opposition to gambling expansion.


Regulatory Actions Across North America

New Jersey and Ontario Impose Fines

Regulators in New Jersey and Ontario have fined several sportsbooks for compliance failures. BetMGM was fined $72,000 for accepting wagers on prohibited events, while bet365 faced a $33,000 penalty for self-exclusion lapses. FanDuel received a $5,000 fine for failing to cooperate during an investigation.

In Ontario, theScore Bet was fined C$200,000 for displaying unachievable cash-out offers on a parlay bet. These enforcement actions underscore the increasing rigor of gambling oversight in regulated markets.


Stake Expands into Alberta’s Regulated Market

Transition from Unregulated Operations

Stake has announced its entry into Alberta’s regulated online gambling market, with a launch planned for October 12. The operator, known for its prominence in offshore markets, will cease unregulated operations in the province as part of its transition. Stake’s move reflects a broader trend toward legitimizing gray-market operators in regulated jurisdictions.


ProphetX Introduces Rival Market Contracts

Innovative Trading Products

ProphetX has filed with the CFTC to offer event contracts tied to the trading volumes of rival prediction markets, including Polymarket US, DKeX, and Rothera. These contracts allow users to speculate on whether these platforms will meet specific volume thresholds, marking a novel approach to market competition.


Polymarket’s Protocol V2 Migration

Enhanced Trading Infrastructure

Polymarket has begun migrating its operations to Protocol V2, introducing new tokens and smart contracts for trading and position management. While existing holdings will not be automatically converted, no technical migration is required for ordinary users beyond completing platform prompts.